Monday, 7 July 2014

July 7 Article Critique; Touching the virtual, touching the real: iPads and enabling literacy for students experiencing disability



Touching the virtual, touching the real: iPads and enabling literacy for students experiencing disability; by Rosie Flewitt, Natalia Kucirkova and David Messer

A convincing article advocating the use of iPads to support student learning across the curriculum, the researchers of this article provide authentic examples within a small sample size demonstrating the efficacy of iPad technology. Specifically, the researchers examine the impact of iPads used to support students with moderate to complex physical and cognitive impairment. It is clear from the research presented that iPads provide a highly interactive and sensory based format for student learning to occur independently, or quasi-independently as determined by specific students.
 It is highly evident that iPads increase student engagement and provide additional avenue for student learning to occur. To validate this reality, it is interesting to examine the various neuroscience and psychological references identified in the article and their connection to student learning. Typically the science behind learning is either miss-understood, or not explained and the success of assistive technology, or other technologies are either embraced as effective if they are deemed as engaging and practical for teachers, or dismissed if the technology is deemed archaic, or cumbersome to use. 

The scientific research presented in this article identifies a clear relationship between the neurological functioning of the human mind and the internal operating design of iPad technologies. As referred to several times in this article, the sensory opportunities resulting from iPad use is important to note. Forever, infants, toddlers and school age children have experienced sensory through touch and feel. Writing letters in the sand, finger painting, moulding clay, etc., all of these tactile materials have complemented learning; digitally however the iPad provides a deeper connection for learners as they benefit from both tactile and digital fulfillment. As the researchers suggest, 

…there is an intricate and entangled relationship between body and mind, which extends to the objects with which a person interacts… Taking sensory experience beyond the realm of the tactile and the tangible, recent work in neuroscience suggests that a neurophysiological mechanism in the human brain- the mirror –neuron mechanism- plays a fundamental role in the human capacity to interpret the actions and sensory experiences of others (Rizzolatti & Craighero, 2004).

In addition to brain-based evidence introduced in the article, it is evident that iPads provide students with varying degrees of cognitive and physical impairment a level of independence they have not experienced to this point in their educational journey. While students with gross motor control impairment are somewhat limited in their ability to use all iPad functions, there is overwhelming evidence from this study that iPads have opened up new learning and inclusion opportunities due to the iPad’s touch-sensitivity and diverse educational apps. 

The portability of the device allows students to work collaboratively, something that is difficult to achieve with stand-alone desktop machines. As mentioned in this article, developing literacy skills for young students is far more successful with the use of iPad apps due to the flexibility and creativity students can employee. As a writing tool, it is very clear that an iPad is far more dynamic and engaging than conventional pencil and paper methods that represented a barrier for many students with complex learning needs.

As mentioned in the article, the responsiveness of iPads allows students to achieve a level of creativity and independence that has been inaccessible with other media. Writing as an example is far more accessible for students as there is less fine motor control required when writing is completed with an iPad as there more emphasis on visual and sensory learning. Vygotsky’s idea of gesture being “writing in the air” is important to recognize as the iPad offers a different learning environment for literacy to occur. Again, according to the evidence presented in this article, iPads have profoundly impacted the learning and independence of students in this small study. Beyond this small sample size it is clear that iPads have tremendous potential as they are a contemporary example of a convergent technology. The emphasis is now on teachers to develop a deeper understanding of iPad function and align this media with existing pedagogical practice. 



Video- iPad for special needs: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=So2eDnKosJc

While there are numerous videos validating the use of iPads on YouTube, this particular video was selected as it demonstrates how students are able to perform curricular tasks independently that otherwise would not have been possible to achieve due to the laborious task of traditional approaches. The iPad has allowed students to demonstrate understanding that otherwise may not have been possible. It’s a quick video worth checking out.     

No comments:

Post a Comment